FuckyWucky [none/use name]

Pro-stealing art without attribution

  • 0 Posts
  • 30 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: March 21st, 2023

help-circle
  • Ayandeh had attracted deposits from millions of ordinary Iranians by offering unusually high interest rates, creating what one Iranian oversight official allegedly described as a “Ponzi scheme.”

    I find it interesting why such a commercial bank was allowed to operate by the regulators. The WSJ article says it was giving bad loans to cronies, so that was definitely the government’s fault. But the bank’s collapse alone doesn’t explain why there was a run out of the rial. It’s easy to blame the collapse of the bank for the collapse of the rial, but I think it’s mostly mainstream economic propaganda. Also, backstopping is literally what all the Western central banks and treasuries did in 2008 and again in 2023, because the banks gave too many loans or held assets which were illiquid, with no inflation, in fact deflation as demand collapsed in 2008. So clearly, it’s not as simple as backstopping deposits.

    I think it could be said that the dual exchange rate system where the central bank offered preferential rates to certain sectors, and rent seekers too, made it much worse, since the official rate was much more rigid, undervalued because the central bank used reserves to maintain it, certain connected people may have used it to run to dollars while the state lost reserves. When it ran out, a massive devaluation was inevitable.

    Also, he doesn’t talk about the mechanics of how he created a dollar shortage. Did they try going after foreign banks Iran worked with, like in Iraq? I think the government is at least partly to blame, but this wouldn’t have happened if Iran weren’t sanctioned.



















  • why do CBDC? SEPA/SEPA Instant already exists and can clear payments just fine without involving VISA/Mastercard. Will people recieve salary in this digital Euro account? probably not because banks lobby, they want cheap funding source i.e. customer deposits. most people wouldn’t want it since there is no interest paid (compared to tiny to moderate interest in savings accounts), you don’t have card even as an option. Like I don’t mind ppl using central bank liabilities for payments but the entire capitalist financial infrastructure is built around commercial banks. its just inconvenient having to transfer money between commercial bank and ECB wallets.

    It won’t destabilize existing financial system or result in bank runs, all banks in the Eurozone are ultimately backstopped by the ECB. bank lending isn’t reserve constrained, it is true that losing cheap deposits may reduce profitability of banks, but that’s it. they will be able to lend just fine because of ECB’s LTROs, TLTROs etc.

    the privacy argument against CBDCs is silly though. Commercial banks ultimately work because of Government, they use Government money for clearing. Governments can just ask them for your data if needed.

    Subsidize SEPA/SEPA Instant. Make it free, a public service. Market it by using the said arguments, people will use it more then. Maybe even force banks to issue cards like Mir in Russia or Unionpay in China.